4.7/5 - (43 votes)

Many students eat breakfast at 8 a.m. on class days and at noon on Saturday. Researchers call that gap “meal timing jetlag,” and a large French study has now looked at whether it relates to heart disease. The answer is more limited than the headlines suggest.

What the researchers measured

A team from INRAE, Inserm and several Paris universities reported their results in Communications Medicine, using data from the NutriNet-Santé cohort. They analyzed 104,806 adults followed between 2009 and 2023.

Participants reported when they had their first and last meal of the day, on weekdays and on weekends. The gap between the two patterns was the “jetlag.” It could go in either direction:

  • Earlier on weekends: meals started about 2 hours earlier on average.
  • About the same: weekday and weekend eating windows nearly matched.
  • Later on weekends: meals shifted about 1 hour 40 minutes later on average.

Heart disease cases were self-reported and then confirmed with medical records. The researchers also adjusted for age, smoking, alcohol, physical activity, diet quality and sleep duration.

What they found

Among men, each extra hour of meal timing jetlag was associated with a 14% higher risk of cardiovascular disease and a 21% higher risk of coronary heart disease. Both the “earlier” and “later” groups showed higher risk than the group with steady mealtimes. Among women, the researchers saw no significant difference.

The team offered possible explanations for the sex difference, including biology, different lifestyles and work situations, and the higher absolute risk of heart disease in men. None of these has been confirmed.

See also  Four ways medical residents relate to patients, and the burnout risk

Bernard Srour, research director at INRAE, said in the Inserm release (translated from French): “Beyond late meals, the regularity of eating rhythms between weekdays and weekends seems just as important.”

Why you should read it carefully

This was an observational study, so it can show an association but not that irregular mealtimes cause heart disease. The researchers themselves say more studies are needed to test cause and effect.

It also was not a study of college students. The participants were adults in France, and heart disease is a long-term outcome that rarely shows up in people in their late teens or early twenties. Nothing in the findings says that sleeping in and brunching on Saturday will harm a student’s heart.

What students can reasonably take from it

The study suggests that consistency may matter on its own, apart from how long you sleep or how healthy your food is. That fits a broader body of research on body clocks, which tend to work best with regular routines.

If your schedule swings widely between weekdays and weekends, that is a pattern worth noticing, not a reason to panic. Questions about your own heart health, eating habits or sleep belong with a doctor or your campus health center.

Quick answers

Does this mean I must eat at the same time every day? No. The study compared averages between weekdays and weekends, and it showed an association, not a rule.

Do the results apply to women? This study found no significant link in women, but that does not prove meal timing is irrelevant for them.

See also  Should you rinse after brushing? What the evidence says